Episode 14
Dr. Sophia Marshall Chapman - Black Man's Burden ch. 7 Discussion
February 1st, 2024
36 mins 4 secs
Season 1
About this Episode
In this engaging discussion between Jean Greene and Dr. Sophia Marshall Chapman, the focus is on Chapter 7 of William Holtzclaw's autobiography, "Black Man's Burden," written in 1915. Dr. Marshall Chapman, a former director of the teacher education preparation program at the Utica Campus of Hinds Community College, provides insightful commentary on the themes found in the chapter. They delve into the challenges Holtzclaw faced, such as navigating classism and adapting to the community's expectations. The conversation also highlights Holtzclaw's ability to connect with diverse individuals, both within and outside the community, demonstrating his commitment to fostering education and opportunities for the students.
Jean and Dr. Marshall explore the enduring impact of Holtzclaw's vision, emphasizing the importance of being intentional in community engagement and drawing parallels to contemporary challenges. They discuss the need for humility, patience, and enduring commitment to a mission, drawing inspiration from Holtzclaw's experiences in building Utica Institute. The conversation goes beyond the historical context, touching on the potential for revitalizing Holtzclaw's legacy in modern times, creating educational programs that address current needs, and establishing partnerships to further educational opportunities. Overall, the dialogue reflects on Holtzclaw's lasting influence and the potential for continued positive change within communities through education.
To support Sips from the Sipp and the Utica Institute Museum, visit our Patreon to become a member!
Support Sips from the SippTranscript
[00:00:00] Thank you for tuning in to Sips from the Sipp. Today we are welcoming to our program, Dr. Sophia Marshall Chapman. Dr. Sophia Marshall Chapman is a former employee of the Utica Campus of Hinds Community College. She, while she was here, was the director of teacher education preparation program. And while she was with that program, she increased the enrollment Exponentially, she had students coming in and working with them and making connections with that program.
She has since moved on with her career and has agreed to come talk to us today about Chapter 7 in Black Man's Burden. Dr. Marshall Chapman. I'm just gonna call you Dr. Marshall. I'm sorry.
Read Full Transcript Hide Full Transcript
That's fine.
That's fine. That's who I was when I was here, so I'm still the same person. So, yes.
So [00:01:00] Black Man's Burden we know was William Holtzclaw's autobiography that he wrote in the early 20th century in 1915.
And each chapter has pushed us, further and further into the mind of William Holtzclaw. when we look at Chapter 7, I just want to discuss with you or have you talk about some of the things you picked up from that chapter.
Okay very well. Several themes that I saw that were resonated throughout the chapter. One being where there's a burden, there's also responsibility and opportunity. Mm
hmm.
And you could see that with some of the things that he encountered and he had to meet those challenges as he was preparing the school.
We also see the theme of classism. And that was, the first part of the chapter, when you start to read it, you can see that there.
And he came in with certain expectations, because [00:02:00] he had experienced something different. He wanted the people around him to experience something different. And he found that to be challenging because what he wanted to bring was not the case and where he was going to take it to. So then you had I saw that throughout the first chapter, the first part of
that
chapter.
Particularly when he starts to talk about One of the persons that own land southwest of Utica,
Mississippi. Right.
And when he saw that person southwest of Utica, Mississippi, how people respected him. But the way that person lived was out of the realms of what he considered to be a classy person or someone in the upper echelon when you talk about class.
Exactly, yes. I I know the part you're talking about. And I, when I was reading it I thought, Well, wait a minute. We, we're talking class and caste here but I don't know if he was trying to inspire folks about this is the level you need to be. And [00:03:00] even though this man had the control of all of this land and people, he wasn't married and he was living with like three or four women or something.
And Holtzclaw was like, no, I don't want to talk to him. Let me talk to somebody
else.
Mm-Hmm. . Mm-Hmm. . Yes. I think he was to me it was as if he was looking for someone who had similar values.
Mm-Hmm. then, and then he didn't want to. Sometimes you can see that people want to, to push their values on someone else.
Yes.
And it hinders their amount of engagement or hinders their amount of being able to accept a person for who they really
are. And he didn't want to accept the fact that this person has so much power, so much control. And in his eyesight, he was not someone that he would want to sit at a table and have a discussion with.
Right, Right. That kind of dovetails with the other thing he mentioned about when he came to the community they weren't [00:04:00] really used to the way he was ready to do things.
And I think about how we look at community now
in this community, even we come in our expectation is like a level 10.
Mm hmm, mm hmm,
And the folks we're talking to, expectations are at like a level three.
Yes, yes.
And
so trying to bridge that distance, do we reach down or do we dismiss these folks because they're not quote unquote on the level we think they need to be?
Or do we try to work with them?
Well, I think he found out quickly that he had to code switch. And when he had to code switch, he had to toss aside all of those things he, well he kept them hidden within him, but he knew how to engage. And I think that was part of what drew the community to
him, in that he knew how to code switch from what he knew to what was accepted with the population that he was dealing [00:05:00] with.
Yeah, and I think he, once he realized that, I think he one part of the book he talked about, How people were paying their tuition. Uh
Huh.
And they really wanted something more
for their
children. Right. So they knew something was out there that was greater than what
they were seeing. But
they didn't have the funds or the financial backing in order to do it.
So they brought in what they had. Which
was
like a
dozen
of eggs. Right,
You know. Or cattle or something of that sort. So they can have an opportunity and give their kids what they did
not have. I
think that was one of the best things
best things read,
that these people really
wanted something
more. And they knew it was something
more. And they trusted someone they did not know, who
had vision, who vision.
to make a
a provision
for their
kids.
Oh, listen at that. Had a vision to make
provision.
For
their children. [00:06:00] So what, what he
was doing
is
Leading
by example and also modeling maybe what he felt his students needed and what the community needed by doing all that.
In other chapters it talks about how he created a society, the Black Belt Improvement Society and the Teachers Extension Movement where the teachers took. A big
role.
That'll come
later in
the
book,
but
I see
here in this chapter where he also, and I'm, I'm shifting just a second, but
he also did not take credit for the school together by himself.
Right, right, right. And I think that was, something that we don't see as much as we need to see. You know, there are people who want to create organizations
They want to create schools. They want to create all these things and they do it under the, the title is good for the community.
But they also want to take credit for it without including community they You know, [00:07:00] it's as if no, I know what's best for you.
So you have to listen to me And that's not how everything works..
I That's true. You have to have community buy-in You have the people on board in order to make venture successful But I really liked how he named these people.
Right, right. Yes, yes. The teachers, he named the teachers, you know, he named the people. I didn't see him name the person who gave him the 50 to buy, buy the quilts for the students, but he gave credit to the person who opened the store. To so he
can
actually purchase the quilts for the students.
Oh, tell that story about what happened with the students and what led him to that.
Well, it was during a time when the weather was really really fierce in this part in this area and the students were cold
were cold.
and
They
actually staged
a protest
I don't blame them..
you know, it's cold. [00:08:00] I want to be warm when I study and at least when I go to sleep. So they met with him in the chapel and when they met with him in the chapel, which I love the fact that he listened to the kids in the chapel, you know, and started students in the chapel.
So when he got to the chapel, the students, mostly females, expressed to him that they're ready to go home. They were done. I know it was cold. I'm tired. You know, I'm paraphrasing, but I'm cold. I'm tired. I can't do this anymore. I didn't buy in for this. I'm ready to go home. He gave a speech to them to remind them of why they
wanted to be here in the first place. what did they want to get from this experience?
He also made a plea to them that if they wanted to go, they could go ahead and go, you know, but don't forget.
Why they
came in the first place and when he finished speaking
to them,
They
changed they
had
a change
of heart
and They went back to their their places where they was trying go to sleep And
do what they were doing So when [00:09:00] he finished his speech and the students went back to their dorms and they
went to sleep
He
Received a
check for 50
And
he
took this
check and He no, he did not know it was coming. It was like, okay, you know, God is making provision for you. Okay. So he went and got some students, some male students, and they went into town and they went to the different stores and they were closed all except for this one person, but he was closed as well.
He knocked on his door. He asked him, would he go to his store and open up so he could get quilts for these young ladies. They got the quilts. Brought them back to the school, and then they wrapped the students around while they were sleeping. And when they got up, one of the young ladies said that it was his speech that kept them warm, you know.
It wasn't even the quilts, it was just the speech that he gave kept him warm. Now, that part, Ms. Green, I have to admit,
I was kind of like, is he full of himself? You know. [00:10:00]
Yeah,
was like, and that was one part too, where I was going, I know he takes creative license in his writing and I was wondering how creative the license was at that point because how did they not know that someone was in there putting these quilts on them, but
When we think about the reason Holtzclaw did the book was to tell stories to potential funders so that they would be able to, you know, Live the story. I can see how he sort of embellished maybe that part. he did something else too that I think we need
to Bear in mind, when those,
those men that he named earlier, those weren't,
They were farmers.
Right.
Most of of them.
farmers. Most of them were tenent farmers.
but they met
every
Monday
night four years.
years, that is [00:11:00] some commitment right there.
Wanting, and that's why it goes back
to the
theme of when there's a burden, there's also opportunity
and there's also responsibility.
Right.
They knew that they didn't want their kids to go under the same things that they had to go under, you know, the, the
hardships, the unpleasantries that they had experienced.
So with them going through those things, they wanted something better for their children.
And If it
meant sacrificing
meant sacrificing their time, they were
willing to do that.
Yeah.
He created a list, a subscription list for people who were interested. I guess that's similar to what we are we talking now a mailing list of folks that are interested.
And one of the things they did with all those meetings is it was just to not only push the school forward, but to keep interest in the community.
And they did a lot of [00:12:00] Potlucks and programs and reaching out to make sure that folks hear the name of the school and they keep their interest up.
And, you know, you may not have a child, but you may know somebody who has a child
that could go to the
school
The school. You know, he, he only planned for
a
certain amount,
but because
the
word and this
was before
and
all
these,
Exactly. You know,
he didn't have the luxuries that
we have
right now, you know, and, and the followers and
the likes,
this
is by word of mouth. And to take it from there to where
we are today. You know, that took a lot,
It
says 6 months
after
starting the
school.
Six
months.
hmm.
Student population
went
[00:13:00] from
20
20 students
Mm hmm.
to
225
students.
115
than it
ever been there before. Attending
school
in
Utica, not just
at
his
school,
but
in
Utica.
Yeah.
Six months,
you
go from
225. I
think about where
we
are now
and what
what we could
do
to
increase the population
now.
to the wheel.
No, No, especially when the foundation is already there. You know, it's when you stay true to the roots and the mission and the vision. There has already been laid for
you.
If you stay true to that, you know, when I was Working here as director of the teacher education preparation
program.
Okay,
we
started out with two
students
two
two one
two
one two And within that
that
time
period we
increased
[00:14:00] to
80
You know, 86, not, not eight, but 80.
And one of the things that I did was go back and find out the foundation. Of the school, the mission to try to get into the spirit of Holtzclaw, not just the grounds, but I wanted to experience the spirit of the school.
What was so enticing about this place that would make students want
to
become teachers because of virtual
questions of normal institute.
Right.
So
with that, and then. One of the other things I saw in this, thing that parallels to what I was doing was he pulled students from everywhere,
not
just
Utica.
They came from all over
the country
by
word
of mouth,
by people telling, you know, I'm sure some family reunions, people were telling people, you need to bring your babies to Utica, you know, when they could have them. Because think about that day in time, [00:15:00] those years, think about how
long it
would
take
a
message
to
get
from
one
place
to
the
other.
That's right.
Like you
said, there was no
social
media.
None.
none,
None. This
was
was
telegram
and snail
mail.
Right.
right.
right. But having the heart
to
want
to
do something and being intentional about
what you're doing. That was one of the things that was throughout this chapter. People being intentional about what they were Even when he had
to go
and
meet
with different people.
That
did
not
look
like
him.
Yes. Yes. Yes.
Yes.
And he had to understand how to engage
with
people
who might, on other circumstances, might not
want
to
engage with him
and what to say and what to do and what not to say and what not to do in the presence
of
others
in order to
bring
him forward, to
bring
him in,
to
get
buy-in
from them.
[00:16:00] Right.
Jim Crow period when, life for any black people is gonna be hard and
you have a,
tightrope you
have to
walk.
Right, right, right. And he was
able to
do
that.
He was able to do that, yes. And I'm sure the one thing that we don't talk about today that we
should
as
far as when we engage with
people is being humble.
is
being humble
was
humble enough to say, let me find out, let me listen.
My grandfather used to say, you have two
ears
and one
mouth for
a
reason.
You
listen twice before you speak
once. And so he was intentional
about he was
intentional One of the things that he,
that was in
the book was
When they were
doing the
military
training,
they had to stop and change the way they were doing
the
the training because
at
one
time
they
were firing
weapons.
and they were [00:17:00] firing them, I think at night, and people were kind of disturbed by why they were over there training and
firing these
weapons.
So
he had to switch and change. They could still
do
the
routines, but they could
not do the weapons.
weapons
That
is so
interesting. Because someone referenced to him, we don't
want
to
have
76
or whatever
the year was.
yes, yes,
uh huh.
what
happened
in
1876?
With the Clinton Riots.
Yeah, it brought up some old feelings from people who remember 1876.
Right, right. And, of course, when they expressed that to him. Then he knew he had to change because he wanted to maintain what he was doing as far as teaching the young men discipline and teaching them how to protect, but he had to do it in a fashion that it would not cause a disturbance in the
community in which
he was working
with. So
he had
to
switch
and
change
from what he
was
doing
[00:18:00] before.
So, modify
behavior in order
to,
when you think about that too, doc we are looking at someone
who
who kept
his
primary goal
in
mind.
Right.
I
want
this
school to thrive.
In
for
it
to thrive,
I've got
to have
this
group
and
This
other group.
Yeah. So he had to have the ear of both the black
community
and
the
non
non-black community.
Why?
Right.
Because, In order for, and I think he says this somewhere earlier in the book, in order for an enterprise to, to be successful,
be successful, you have to involve
your whole community.
right, right, you do. I mean, that goes without, you know, think about the, big
corporations,
you know.
They have something,
a message
that,
can reach people
that
are not
in those
boardrooms
with
They
know [00:19:00] how to talk and how to reach people by speaking
their
language,
by embracing them
in some capacity in order to
they
what they are.
You know, a lot of them started off, I'm
sure,
you know, when you go into the grocery store,
they used
to give
the samples out.
Oh yeah. And,
you had a sample, then you might Wanna go and purchase this
particular
product. Mm-Hmm. .Some of those very same samples are the reason we have
these
big
corporations
now.
Huh. That's
how he started you. That's how he
get you hooked. Yes, and
when she
wrote she wasn't with him,
at first. Mm-Hmm. . She was at home. Mm hmm.
Mm hmm. Yes. Yes. And when she wrote those
letters telling him, look, I don't care what you're going through. I'm ready to come to see [00:20:00] y'all. I want to be with my husband, you know.
was like, no, no,
And he was like, no, no, no.
You know, cause he knew that she would be uncomfortable being that she
was
an elite
person
from the
city.
a city.
She's a city girl.
And here she is going to, she has to come all the way to Utica, you know, in order to be with him. And she was like, I don't care. You know, he's like, I know she's accustomed to the finer shops.
She's accustomed to the stove. That's right.
That's right.
because she had to
cook over it up. Well,
oven. She didn't
actually
cook
over the
oven. Right, right,
right. right. But I love the part that she says that was the best meals. Like, that's the way to keep them cooking for you, you know. Like, oh, those are the best meals I've ever had, you know.
Do it
do again.
it again. told her that he was living in a place not much different from the way he was teaching outside. And then he described where they were [00:21:00] living and that she had to make the
bed
bed ticks
out
of what
the old
folks
called crocusacks.
And I'm like, crocusacks?
I
remember
that term.
That's
a burlap bag.
That's not
the most
comfortable
thing
to be
lying
on.
no. And
then she had to stuff it with
hay from
the field.
Right, right. But
she didn't
care as long as she was kept warm by
she was kept warm by his
love. Oh, and then they had to share the house with the little one room house that didn't have second
floor. They had
to lay
the
planks across
the
joists.
And
then
when
they got some boarding students, too,
the
boy had
to stay
with him
and
the girl
had
to
to sleep Mm-Hmm. . But he
kept going. Right. Right. No matter what The
other students
that they
had had to be
boarded with families
in the
area.
area
Mm-Hmm.
Mm-Hmm. . Mm-Hmm. . Yeah. But you think about it, if it's something that you really want, you don't care. [00:22:00] uncomfortable you might
As long as you achieve what you really, really want. If
it's your
heart's desire, you know, if it's something that is
your mission,
your passion,
then you endure until you realize that that you really want. The difference is now a lot of people want instant everything, instant coffee, instant grits.
instant everything.
I
need it right now.
But
when
they develop
The character and the patience that they need in order to get those things they really want and reap the benefits from sowing those seeds of patience and sowing those seeds of endurance. When they get that ultimate reward,
it
lasts
longer.
He created something that lasts
generations.
You know, think about it. Not only did he
have
this
vision.
And that he created this, but he created something that would change generations
of
[00:23:00] people. Think about all the people who've
graduated from
Utica.
They have
changed not only Utica, not only themselves, but they've changed communities.
Think about
you're talking about
Congressman
Bennie Thompson,
a
graduate,
here.
And he
sits on standing committees for the United
States of
America, you know, and it started with
Holtzclaw's vision.
He knew, he didn't know that he would be able to influence
a
congressman. People who make laws for this country. He didn't know that what he was doing would be influencing
presidents of colleges throughout the country.
You know? Musicians and teachers and all of these great people that came
through Utica.
But he knew
he
had
to
do
it.
Right.
You
know, it's like, that is a itch that you've got to scratch it, you know, you've got to do this for [00:24:00] people that you don't even,
that
hadn't
even
been born.
You know, their parents had not even
been born.
But you have to do this because you know it's going to impact more
people
than just
your,
your
little
circle.
That's right.
and I think that's, that's so thank
you,
you that,
that's so important for us now.
Mm-Hmm.
We
have to look past our
own
personal wants and our own personal rewards.
And sometimes we have to look at the fact that we are repaid. I'm putting that in quotation marks. By the lives that we influence, and what they go on and do. They don't necessarily have to come back and say, You know Dr. Marshall, that was really cool what you did. But you can
observe
the
results
of
your
seeds you planted.
Right.
You
may see this written in a news program. You may see this new[00:25:00] president of a college.
You
may
hear
of an Olympic
athlete.
There
are so many people that have been touched and influenced, like you said, about, by Holtzclaw's vision and how it has been perpetuated through the years. We need to
jump
back
into
that
bandwagon and
push
that
vision
forward.
It
would be
interesting if we
could,
you
and I
talked
about this years
ago.
We
talked about
a
freedom
school. Which was,
if, I'm remembering
correctly, now
old,
but
if
I'm
remembering
correctly,
you
called
it
the Holtzclaw School.
Yes,
yes,
yes, yes. And currently I'm working with the Hinds county ministerial alliance to create a string freedom
school
in
Bolton, Mississippi.
Wow.
Yes, and so they, it was a extended learning desert. [00:26:00] There was nothing there at first. Now there's another one, but this will be one that is geared towards stream science, technology, reading, engineering, arts, and mathematics. We could have easily
have
done
that here
and had the teachers that we were preparing to work inside of
that Freedom
School.
You know, thinking about how and use some of the things that he did, the fireside chats that he had in order to get people on the same page
in order
to
work
the school.
Some of the same character things that he did as far as character development,
we
could done that
with
students
here
as
well.
And
we can still do
it if
we
can
re inspire.
the
folks
who
come
past here,
who come
through here. I
Tell
the story about when
I first came,
way
back
in
2000,
and I
knew
nothing about
Holtzclaw.
But
because I was [00:27:00] inspired by the people I was working with and they told me the story and they
told
me the
story
and they
told
me the
story
and
they were
living
the story.
These people who didn't even meet Holtzclaw, some of them weren't even born when Holtzclaw was
here.
But they had been
touched
by
his
vision in this space. So one of the things that we want to do with this program and
with our programs at the museum is we're trying to touch lives so
we
can
reignite
that
spark.
Yes, yes, yes.
And, make sure that
that vision, that
mission doesn't falter.
Yes, yes. And I think
one
of
the things
that
hasn't been tapped into,
there's
so many resources that are here. You have a perfectly wonderful space out that you can actually look into creating [00:28:00] opportunities for students in the areas of climate
and
environmental justice.
You right
here.
You know. Not
too
far from.
different locations throughout Hines County and Copiah County, that you can really look at what's going on in the community and in the climate and in the environment that
might
impact
the community. There are so many different programs that can be developed with this being one of the places that can do that.
Why not? I mean, this has been a a really great place, an incubator
for
success.
So if you start here with developing programs that students might not see when they go in other places, then just think
about
how
they can take
off, you know. There are so many different opportunities for students to go to
the
old
high
school,
to
reinvent
that.
to
reinvent it into becoming
a
stream school
in this area of Hinds County. You have the arts. [00:29:00] This was a Mecca for people who wanted to be in the arts. Thanks to Dr Cooper and all those who are for him. But why not use that as a place to welcome people so they can have these different skills and go out and do music technology and arts.
have the perfect location for all those things to happen. It's just a matter of people looking into the resources and making wise decisions regarding them. And keeping that vision and mission at the forefront of what they're
engaging
in. And keeping that in the forefront of when you're engaging
with your sponsors.
You
know, and talking to the community at large. There's no reason why this could not be as monumental of a movement when it comes to education as some of those bigger places out. You know, there, he talked about having the
president
of
Tougaloo
College
Mm-Hmm.
to
come.
And when they were working with it, it was, [00:30:00] at that time, it was Tougaloo University, you know.
Uhhuh,
So having Tougaloo University come here to Hinds and understanding the relationships that
they had
during
that time. And that still is needed. You still have to have those relationships because when students leave here,
they
have to go.
to go somewhere.
So why not cultivate those relationships with those, not only with HBCUs, but with all the other schools that want to engage and have your students come out?
Because, you know, we're creating, we're preparing students now for problems
we
don't
even
we have.
have. Right.
We're preparing them to address the problems that have not
even
surfaced yet.
Right.
Who would have thought that we had
to
endure COVID 19?
19? Exactly who would've thought that it was gonna take a, a person of color to help
find a solution,
to
help us to go out and breathe again?
You know? But she was there. Who would've thought that there would be someone [00:31:00] I know most of our interactions was over Zoom. Mm-Hmm. . But it took a, a sister of color to help create that platform so we can go out and do that. So here's an opportunity for us
to
nurture
students.
Create platform
for
them to go and develop their, thinking skills to, meet some of these
thinking skills to, to meet some of these challenges that
we
haven't
faced yet. And instead of doing that, we want to recreate a wheel that's already spinning fine somewhere else. Instead of pulling
something new
in
and
making
this space
as
unique
as
it
was
was when Holtzclaw first started.
Yes. The was [00:32:00] opportunity is here started in a started. They came here because they heard that somebody was preparing students for
future.
hmm.
Just think about what would happen if people heard that Utica
was
preparing
students
for the
future.
future
And they came even when
he
didn't
have the resources
to house them to the
programs to,
to
operate
with
them. But they
knew
he was sincere and pushing and doing
this
to
improve
his people.
Right, right, right. And so he had established.
Now he was a true person that that showed everyone was
servant leadership
was about,
Mm hmm.
you know, he showed people what servant leadership
really
meant
When you get out and you find your [00:33:00] niche and you find out that this is fitting some situation or some problems and you're helping people to work through those problems and work and give them opportunities
to
do
so.
You know, think about how people are drawn because when you look at society, you look at people, they're really trying to
find
their
voice.
Yes.
They're trying to find some place for themselves to feel like their life means something. And the students that he brought in really found that
their life meant something.
a
lot
jobs,
that increased to larger jobs.
but
So I think that's one of the things that
get back to that.
That's true. That's true. Well Dr. Marshall Chapman, I want to thank you for joining us today
to
have
this
discussion.
I
knew
when
you
came
it
was going to be
interesting. to be interesting.
Well,
thank thank you.
you
I hope that maybe we can get you back [00:34:00] sometime. And we can delve deeper into the vision you have for what we can do here as well. But thank you so much
and
we'll
check you
next time.
time. Thank you. Thank you.